poster
Corporate work

EOS Constitution Referendum: When Democracy Meets Blockchain

EOS.IO is a blockchain protocol, developed by a private company block.one, which has published a White paper for the EOS.IO project back in 2017. The company raised funds via an ICO, collecting more than 4 billion U.S. dollars, claiming to develop a new groundbreaking blockchain architecture.

In September 2017, developers have published the EOS.IO Dawn 1.0, followed by Dawn 2.0, Dawn 3.0 and Dawn 4.0 with consequent updates. Finally, EOSIO 1.0 launched in June 2018.

EOS project aimed to eliminate shortcomings in existing blockchain protocols. The architecture was designed to build decentralized applications. Thus, the software provides accounts, authentication, databases, asynchronous communication, and the scheduling of applications across many central processing units cores or clusters.

Key features of the EOS.IO are:

1) Minimized latency: the system can currently process up to 3998 transactions per second, which has the potential to be multiplied using sidechains.

2) Actions can be delivered to and accepted by multiple accounts atomically.

3) All EOS.IO accounts can be referenced by a unique human-readable name of up to 12 characters in length, chosen by the account`s creator, with an opportunity to have unique shorter names.

4) Multi-user account control with a system of control levels (e.g. “Friend”, “Lawyer”) tied to respective keys, which create a hierarchical structure.

5) The software provides an account owner with an opportunity to use any owner key, active in the last 30 days along with approval from their designated account recovery partner to reset the owner key.

6) EOS.IO also introduces a novelty governance system, with a Constitution being an integral part of it, making EOS a governed blockchain.

Legal nature of the EOS Constitution

A governed blockchain is a permissionless blockchain (meaning, anyone can join the network) with legally binding rules of entry and participation.

Although collocation “governed blockchain” might not make much sense at first, as it defies the nature of the distributed system, a governed blockchain simply utilizes a formalized set of willingly accepted rules, known as the Constitution; and there is no centralized “parliament” that enacts these rules.

Therefore, EOS Constitution is a peer-to-peer Terms of Service Agreement or a binding multilateral Contract for those users who sign it, which sets forth:

          1) user`s and block producer`s obligations;

          2) dispute resolution procedure by establishing jurisdiction and the choice of law;

          3) human-readable intent of the source code protocol;

          4) voting rules; and

          5) other accepted terms.

Just like “traditional” constitutions that are aggregates of fundamental rules of the state, EOS Constitution establishes a “rule of law” within the network. However, the material scope of the EOS Constitution is obviously much narrower.

Considering that EOS Constitution is still, after all, a Service Agreement, referred to as the “Constitution”, it follows the rules of offer and acceptance as in contract law, though adapted to a distributed network.

EOS Constitution Referendum

As a new Constitution is currently in development, with multiple drafts introduced, a community will choose a new Constitution on a referendum with a supermajority voting.

Pursuant to the currently effective version, in order for a Constitution to be adopted, token holders with no less than 15% participation have to vote no fewer than 10% more “Yes” than “No” votes (meaning, with at least 55% voting “Yes”).

“EOS Community Constitution, New York, and block.one (that is expected to be published shortly) versions are most likely to be submitted for a referendum as the most sustainable and closely updated versions. While working on EOS Community Constitution we took into consideration different points of view, as far as many EOS teams around the globe used to work on it”, says Dmitri Prokopenko, Co-Founder at MEET.ONE and co-author of one of the drafts.

Both currently available drafts establish the fundamental principles of the EOS blockchain code use, such as:

          1) supreme legal force of the Constitution and an obligation to abide by it in an event of ownership of EOS tokens;

          2) freedom to a contract;

          3) rules of dealing with inflation;

          4) voting rules and amendment procedures.

However, the drafts seem to reflect slightly different legal opinions of its authors. For example, the NY draft formally recognizes The New York Convention of 1958 allowing foreign arbitral awards to be recognized so long as the award author is registered on-chain, while the ECC edition simply sets forth freedom to choose an arbiter or a court to resolve a dispute.

In addition, the inflation rate is set at 1% in both drafts, but the New York edition does not allow it to be raised on a referendum, unlike the other one.

Besides, Community version also prohibits any person to own or control more than 10% of the EOS tokens, includes provisions on intellectual property, liability and damages, as well as an opportunity to introduce additional agreements and documents through a referendum lite, that shall be in compliance with the Constitution (just like provisions of state’s constitutions are interpreted in more details in laws and other legal acts).

Regardless of the ECC draft containing more detailed provisions on a broader material scope, the NY version holds a great “constitutionalization” potential, with Ricardian contracts being an integral part of the proposed text.

Ricardian contracts are read by robots and computers alike, which means they can be executed electronically, opening more opportunities to facilitating the provision of legal services”, says Max Maliuk, CTO at Legal Nodes.

Changes to the Constitution: another form of direct democracy

The constitutional process also traditionally includes the rules of adopting changes to constitutions. EOS Constitution is no different.

To amend the Constitution, the amended text has to receive an approval of 15 out of 21 block producers and maintain it for 30 consecutive days. Block producers then adopt changes to the source code to reflect the change in the constitution and propose it to the blockchain using the hash of the new constitution.

After that, block producers have to maintain approval of the new code for 30 consecutive days. Changes to the code come into effect in 7 days, which gives non-producing nodes time to upgrade after the ratification.

Conclusion

The “constitutional process” unfolding around the EOS Constitution lets us witness how blockchain industry can wisely apply legal concepts that are normally used in drastically different fields of law to the distributed ledger technology.

With multiple forms of direct democracy, arbitration, reduced latencies, free use and endless possibilities to develop blockchain products, EOS blockchain protocol has the potential to disrupt the industry and change the way we are used to applying legal categories to already existing social relations. 

Disclaimer: the information in this article is provided for informational purposes only. You should not construe any such information as legal, tax, investment, trading, financial, or other advice.

Nik Kliapets, Legal Counsel at Legal Nodes

Legal Nodes Blog

For Startups
Ultimate guide to connecting Virtual Data Protection Officer

Connecting Virtual DPO can greatly reduce start-up’s data protection costs. This article explains who the Data Protection Officer is, why you should consider outsourcing DPO services, and how to pick one that matches the needs of your business....

Legal Nodes Team
Privacy (GDPR)
Cookie Policy: How to Track Website Users Lawfully

The recent study of the Nederlandse Omroep Stichting (the ‘NOS’), a Dutch news media, showed that more than 1,300 Dutch websites violate the privacy of their users. The violation found by the NOS is simple - the users cannot use the websites wit...

Legal Nodes Team
For Startups
Why Your Startup Needs a Founders' Agreement + Template 2021

Founders Agreement – the key step to set clear intentions for you and your partners and to avoid misunderstandings in the future. In a new post on the Legal Nodes blog, we explain what a Founders Agreement is, reasons for your startup to prepare...

Legal Nodes Team
For Startups
Terms of Use that your users will actually read

In this article Legal Nodes Team talks about Terms of Use, how to write them effectively and why you need them in the first place. You could find a FREE template at the end of this article....

Legal Nodes Team
Privacy (GDPR)
How Can You Leverage a Privacy Kit More Effectively?

In this article, Punit Bhatia, a leading privacy expert, shares how small businesses can become privacy compliant by using Privacy Kits in an effective and why just branding the documents and templates in name of your company is not a good idea....

Punit Bhatia
Legal Nodes Updates
Legal Nodes in 2020: A Year in Review

Despite the fact that for many 2020 will be strongly associated with the coronavirus pandemic and lockdown measures, it would be a mistake to forget all the good things that happened this year. Especially when the festive season approaches, and ...

Legal Nodes Team
Privacy (GDPR)
Internet data mining. Is it legal in the EU?

Data mining is the process of collecting and analyzing human-readable data for own purposes. More and more businesses are built on that concept, scientists and medics also use automatically combined data from different sources to spawn predictio...

Ewa Wojnarska-Krajewska
Privacy (GDPR)
11 simple (but complete) steps towards the GDPR compliance in 2020

The GDPR can be a wake-up call to sort out your processes, procedures and technology and thereby run a more successful organisation. Data is now more essential than ever, regardless of your activities or market sector. Not only will efficiencies...

Thomas Hayes
Contract Work
Force Majeure Clauses and the Effect of Coronavirus on Businesses

The coronavirus pandemic has made force majeure clauses one of the hottest legal topics worldwide. To help businesses navigate this issue, we asked Tom Bohills, an English qualified lawyer and the Founder of Chronos Law, to explain the backgrou...

Tom Bohills